One holds the food. The other never touches it.
Verdict
These do different jobs, and the honest answer is that many couples need neither. Heavy plastic plates with a gold rim are what guests eat off when there is no rental china. Charger plates sit under the real plate purely as decoration and are removed before food arrives. If a caterer or venue is providing china, buy chargers only, and only if you want them. If you are self catering, buy the dinner plates and skip the chargers entirely.
~$24
Check Gold Rim Plastic Plates, 60 piece set Price~$30
Check Clear Charger Plates with Gold Rim, 16 pack Price| Gold Rim Plastic Plates, 60 piece set | Clear Charger Plates with Gold Rim, 16 pack | |
|---|---|---|
| Food goes on it | Yes | No |
| Included in most catering packages | No | No |
| Included with most rental china | No | Sometimes |
| Cost per guest | Under fifty cents | Around two dollars |
| Removed before the meal | No | Yes |
| Needed at all | If self catering | Never |
You are self catering or working with a caterer who does not supply tableware. Heavy weight plates with a metallic rim look considerably better than they cost and do not fold when someone puts a full plate of food on them, which the cheap ones do. Buy about twenty percent more than your guest count, because people take second plates.
Check Gold Rim Plastic Plates, 60 piece set on Amazon
You want the table to look layered and finished in photographs and everything else is already handled. A charger is pure decoration, so treat it as a decor line rather than as tableware. Check whether your rental company already includes chargers in the place setting price, because a lot do and it is a common duplicate purchase.
Check Clear Charger Plates with Gold Rim, 16 pack on Amazon
Heavier plastic plates with a rim read as intentional rather than as picnic ware, especially on a dressed table. The weight is what sells it. Thin flexible plates are noticed immediately and are the false economy in this category.
Usually not on price alone, but rentals typically include collection and washing, which is real work someone has to do at midnight otherwise. Factor labour and bin space into the comparison, not just the sticker price.
Disposables generate a lot of waste for one evening. Compostable options exist but need a facility that actually composts them, which many areas do not have. Rental china is the lower impact answer where it is affordable.
Comparison based on published manufacturer specifications and the general consensus of owner reports. We have not tested these units side by side. Confirm current prices and specifications before buying. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.
We also have a full Nervure gold plastic plates review.